When landlords owed rent by a failed letting agent asked the liquidators questions, the answers came from the liquidators’ solicitor, Andrew Laycock of Prosperity Law. Most questions went unanswered. The bill for not answering them goes to the creditors.
Andrew Laycock is a solicitor at Prosperity Law LLP. In the liquidation of Coopers Residential Ltd he acts for the liquidators, Frost Group. He does not act for the landlords and tenants owed about £496,000. But he has confirmed that his fees are charged to the liquidation, which means they are paid out of the money that would otherwise go to those landlords and tenants. The story so far is in 07B and 07F.
On 23 September Mr Laycock wrote to creditors:
“At no point has the creation of a creditors committee been opposed by our clients… every regulation has been properly adhered to.”
His clients’ own Record of Decision shows the committee was put to a vote and defeated by 97 per cent, every vote against cast by the company’s director as chair, most of it on a claim the director made with his own solicitor against his own company. Mr Frost had already told creditors on a recorded call that a committee would only “add to our costs”. Five days later Mr Laycock wrote that the committee position at the meeting “was confusing”.
By early October creditors had put 25 written requests to the liquidators. Twenty-one had gone unanswered. On 13 October Mr Laycock replied to a list of nineteen questions. He answered seven. Among the answers:
“No undertaking has been requested from Brett Holt.”
“It is not understood what a ‘standstill’ represents?”
On costs: “Confirmed. To be agreed.”
Brett Holt is the law firm whose client account received more than £300,000 from the sale of the directors’ building, eleven days before the liquidation. Asking it to hold that money for creditors was the one protective step creditors asked for. The answer was that nobody had asked. Asked whether the liquidators had requested that the sale proceeds be held, he replied: “No.” Asked whether anyone at Frost Group advised on the £1 transfer of the business to the solicitor’s company, he replied: “No.”
The same letter opened by telling creditors that advice taken “is a cost to the estate”, and that if they objected to those costs, the liquidator might apply to court, where “the contents of your extensive correspondence would be placed before the court”. Earlier, on 7 October, he wrote to one creditor’s representative that having to reply was “unfortunately increasing the costs of the liquidation”. A week later he attributed the costs to creditors’ “repeated enquiries”.
In our view that is the whole pattern in two sentences. Creditors ask where their money went. The solicitor declines most of the questions, charges for declining them to the money the creditors are owed, and then tells them the bill is their fault for asking.
When creditors said they would seek to replace the liquidators, Mr Laycock wrote on 14 October that “the liquidator suggests that you take immediate steps to request the removal of the duly appointed liquidators”. Removing a liquidator requires creditors holding a quarter of the debts, a replacement’s written consent and a deposit towards the costs. By that week, the directors were paying creditors off one by one under their solicitor’s settlement letters, and every creditor paid was a signature lost. The invitation came when it was hardest to accept.
On deposits, the liquidators’ position moved with each letter. One creditor’s tenant’s deposit, which the company never protected, was “not a debt due” to her. Then it was a matter of “agreement or determination”. Then the deposit “wasn’t and isn’t” hers, though “No adjudication has been made as yet on this or the other proofs of debt”. Meanwhile, the directors’ solicitor was proposing to route deposits into an account in the name of his own company. Mr Laycock wrote that working out “the how and where to of these transfers forms part of the liquidators’ duties”. Creditors have still not been told the answer.
Mr Laycock has said that the liquidators’ conduct information “will of course be considered”, that a committee would be formed once enough creditors were nominated, and that the liquidators are investigating “the situation relating to the Trust Accounts”. The committee was formed on 9 November. If Prosperity Law wishes to reply, we will publish its reply here in full.
Ask the liquidator, in writing, whether his solicitor’s fees are being charged to the estate, at what rate and how much so far. Ask for the committee to see and approve those costs. A liquidator’s solicitor acts for the liquidator, not for you, but you pay for him. Keep every letter, count the questions answered against the questions asked, and put that count in front of the committee and the regulator.
Everything above is quoted from Prosperity Law’s and Frost Group’s letters and emails to creditors, and from Frost Group’s Record of Decision, with copies kept.
END TRANSMISSION 07J
We’re publishing often at the moment. One email when the next one lands, if you ask for it.
Ask for the one email →